[ ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER NO. 77, July 11, 1988 ]
SUSPENDING DONATO T. JIMENEZ, ASSISTANT FISCAL OF ILAGAN, ISABELA
This is an administrative case for immorality against Donato T. Jimenez, Assistant Fiscal of Ilagan, Isabela.
In her letter-complaint of April 28, 1985, Ruth P. Macarubbo charged respondent fiscal with immorality, alleging that: a) in 1982, while she was employed as private secretary of respondent, then a private practitioner, she was asked to accompany him to several places; b) during these trips, respondent succeeded in having carnal relations with her and, thereafter, she occasionally cohabited with him at our house at Gosi, Tuguegarao, Cagayan from then on and up to February 14, 1985 when the promise to share me one half of his earnings was only partially fulfilled; and c) as a result of this illicit relationship we begot a son named Rudon Macarubbo Jimenez on February 2, 1984.
To substantiate her claim, complainant presented two letters from respondent which the latter sent to her while he was in the United States.
In his answer of June 27, 1985, respondent denied complainant s allegations and endeavoured to show that Macarubbo was a woman of ill-repute. While he admitted to having sent the two letters and the sum of money indicated therein, respondent claimed that the same was given because of humanitarian consideration when Ms. Macarubbo pleaded and begged to send money because she was in financial distress and in bad need of money.
After due investigation, the provincial fiscal of Isabela recommended that the case against respondent be dismissed and considered closed.
Upon review, however, the Secretary of Justice found that, although the imputed immoral acts commenced when respondent was still a law practitioner, his letter dated September 6 and October 9, 1984 suggests quite plaintively that he still felt some degree of affection for complainant. Consequently, in his memorandum to the President, dated February 1, 1988, the Justice Secretary recommended that respondent be suspended for thirty (30) days, stating that:
WHEREFORE, and as recommended by the Secretary of Justice, Donato T. Jimenez, Assistant Fiscal of Ilagan, Isabela, is hereby suspended from office for thirty (30) days, effective upon receipt of a copy of this Order.
Done in the City of Manila, this 11th day of July, in the year of Our Lord, nineteen hundred and eighty-eight.
By the President:
(Sgd.) CATALINO MACARAIG, JR.
Executive Secretary
In her letter-complaint of April 28, 1985, Ruth P. Macarubbo charged respondent fiscal with immorality, alleging that: a) in 1982, while she was employed as private secretary of respondent, then a private practitioner, she was asked to accompany him to several places; b) during these trips, respondent succeeded in having carnal relations with her and, thereafter, she occasionally cohabited with him at our house at Gosi, Tuguegarao, Cagayan from then on and up to February 14, 1985 when the promise to share me one half of his earnings was only partially fulfilled; and c) as a result of this illicit relationship we begot a son named Rudon Macarubbo Jimenez on February 2, 1984.
To substantiate her claim, complainant presented two letters from respondent which the latter sent to her while he was in the United States.
In his answer of June 27, 1985, respondent denied complainant s allegations and endeavoured to show that Macarubbo was a woman of ill-repute. While he admitted to having sent the two letters and the sum of money indicated therein, respondent claimed that the same was given because of humanitarian consideration when Ms. Macarubbo pleaded and begged to send money because she was in financial distress and in bad need of money.
After due investigation, the provincial fiscal of Isabela recommended that the case against respondent be dismissed and considered closed.
Upon review, however, the Secretary of Justice found that, although the imputed immoral acts commenced when respondent was still a law practitioner, his letter dated September 6 and October 9, 1984 suggests quite plaintively that he still felt some degree of affection for complainant. Consequently, in his memorandum to the President, dated February 1, 1988, the Justice Secretary recommended that respondent be suspended for thirty (30) days, stating that:
. . . there exists a dire necessity for a high and unswerving sense of morality that should pervade public office especially where the thrust of this government is to infuse high moral and ethical standards in the public service. Any cloud of suspicion on the moral and professional integrity of a public officer must be dispelled. Although in cases of this nature, direct evidence to substantiate the charge, is as a general rule, wanting, we cannot however disabuse ourself of the suspicion that respondent s illicit relation with the complainant subsisted even after his appointment to public office. I agree with the Secretary of Justice. As public office is a public trust, all government officials and employees, whether high or low, should at all times, be morally upright. It cannot be overemphasized that, if only to infuse high moral and ethical standards in the public service, every public official should be imbued with a high sense of morality consistent with the responsibilities called for by his position and fairly reflective of the trust reposed in him by the public. Any pall of doubt on his moral and professional integrity should be eschewed outright.
WHEREFORE, and as recommended by the Secretary of Justice, Donato T. Jimenez, Assistant Fiscal of Ilagan, Isabela, is hereby suspended from office for thirty (30) days, effective upon receipt of a copy of this Order.
Done in the City of Manila, this 11th day of July, in the year of Our Lord, nineteen hundred and eighty-eight.
(Sgd.) CORAZON C. AQUINO
President of the Philippines
President of the Philippines
By the President:
(Sgd.) CATALINO MACARAIG, JR.
Executive Secretary